What Is a CEMA and Why Does It Matter in New York?
A CEMA is one of those New York quirks that doesn't exist in most other states, and it can meaningfully affect the cost of refinancing a mortgage here.
- Avoids double-paying recording tax on a refinance
- Only applies to the portion already taxed once
- Not automatic - has to be arranged
Talk Through Your Options
No obligation - a local loan officer will walk you through what fits your situation.
You're all set.
A member of the Coltrain team will reach out shortly.
No cost, no obligation. A member of our team will follow up directly.
The Problem CEMA Addresses
Mortgage recording tax is a tax charged when a mortgage is recorded, calculated on the loan amount. Normally, refinancing means recording an entirely new mortgage, which would mean paying recording tax again on the full new loan amount, even though you already paid it once on your original mortgage.
A CEMA exists specifically to avoid double-paying recording tax on the portion of your balance that's already been taxed once - not to eliminate the tax altogether on new money being borrowed.
How a CEMA Works
A Consolidation, Extension and Modification Agreement restructures the transaction so that, instead of the new loan fully replacing the old one for tax purposes, the existing mortgage is assigned to the new lender and then consolidated, extended, and modified into the new loan terms. Because the original mortgage debt is treated as continuing rather than being paid off and re-originated from scratch, recording tax is generally only owed on any new money being added on top of the existing balance, not the entire new loan amount.
When a CEMA Is Used
CEMAs typically come up in refinance transactions, and the specifics of whether one is available depend on things like whether the original mortgage assignment can be properly structured and whether the new lender participates in CEMA transactions. It's not automatically part of every refinance - it needs to be arranged as part of the transaction.
Is It Worth Pursuing?
The potential recording tax savings from a CEMA can be significant on a sizable refinance balance, but the transaction can also involve additional coordination and paperwork between the old and new lender. Whether it's worth pursuing for your specific refinance is worth discussing directly with a loan officer familiar with New York CEMA transactions.
Frequently asked
What is a CEMA and why does it matter in New York?+
A CEMA, or Consolidation, Extension and Modification Agreement, is a New York-specific refinance structure that can reduce how much of a new loan is subject to mortgage recording tax, potentially saving the borrower a meaningful amount at closing.
Does every New York refinance use a CEMA?+
No. A CEMA is typically used when refinancing with the existing lender or when the original mortgage assignment can be structured to qualify, and it isn't automatically part of every refinance.
Do all lenders offer CEMA refinances?+
Not universally - CEMA transactions have specific requirements and paperwork, so it's worth confirming directly whether a lender supports this structure for your situation.
Related guides
Have questions about your specific situation?
Every borrower's situation is different - talk to a Coltrain Mortgage loan officer.